Review Of Herman And Chomsky Essay Example for Free

Re calculate Of Herman And Chomsky EssayThe Manufacturing Consent of media operations written and applied by Edward Herman and Noam Chomsky say that elect(ip) group mass media atomic number 18 united and interlocked with other institutional sectors in ingestership, management and social circles. In egalitarian societies mass media plays an important office. They respond to creation concerns and create aw beness to the ground policies important change surfacets and view points.The complete principles of democracy depend upon the nonion of a reasonably informed electorate that reflects public opinion and respond to public concerns Media is an integral intermit of the society, media need non be controlled or set to a pattern they carry united with other sectors. (European daybook of parley 2002, pg.147).Herman and Chomskys propaganda model has been named as conspiracy theory because of its unflinching view of media behavior, according to them mass media ar instrume nts of power that mobilize support for special interests that dominate the state and private activity and mass media acts in unison with other sectors, i.e. the academy, to establish, enforce, reinforce and police corporeal hegemony. (European Journal of Communication 2002, pg148) . Herman and Chomsky reject the conspiracy label however the Manufacturing Consents emphasis is on motives of media behavior, in relation to institutional controls.(Herman and Chomsky 1988,pg 1-35).The model assumes that media designs should be explained in structural footing. According to Herman and Chomsky there are quintuplet major distorting mechanisms which structure the parole content. The authors admit that propaganda model cannot give e really detail of such a complex matter as the working of the content mass media, the model does not assume that news reporters, editors and other workers are instructed or typic altogethery compelled to omit some voices and emphasize others, the model come fo rthlines circumstances down the stairs which media leave behind be comparatively open or closed.As micro-analysis is not the task of the Propaganda Model, it merely provides an oerview of the system at work, making sense out of a confusing picture by removing the chief(prenominal) principles of the system, the basic argument in this context is that meanings are easily filtered by restrictions that are made in the system. The authors argue that meanings are formed at odd levels, as the decisions are understood to be indwelling and sensible, however the authors do not imply that newsroom workers always make decisions to align themselves with the interests of the dominant elites.(Rai,1995pg46)Herman and Chomsky publish that all news material goes through five inter related filter restrictions. Leaving only cleansed eternal sleep fit to be printed.(Herman and Chomsky1988pg 3-14). The five filter elements are (1) the size, concentrated ownership, owners wealth, and profit orienta tion course of the dominant mass-media (2) advertising as the primary income source of the mass media. (3) the reliance of the media on information provided by government, business, and experts funded and approved by the primary sources and agents of power. (Martin and Knight 1997,pg 253-254). (4) Opposition as government agency of disciplining the media (5) anti-communism as a national religion and control mechanism.(Herman ,cited in Wintonick and Achbar,1994pg108).The first filter restriction emphasizes that media are closely interlinked and share frequent interests with other dominant sectors as corporations, the state, and banks. The dominant media sectors are large firms with large businesses they are controlled by very wealthy volume or by their managers who are subject to sharp restrictions by the owners. The second filter emphasizes that the news production process is exceedingly influenced by advertising values , most(prenominal) media must sell markets(readers) to buye rs(advertisers).This dependance can directly influence media performance, Chomsky remarks that media content reflects the interests of the sellers, the buyers, and the product .Herman make loves that the application of the first and second filters of the propaganda model has greatly influenced the economy the communications industries, and politics went through dramatic changes the two filters ,ownership and advertising have become even more important. The third filter is the news gathering process, the dominant elite provide press releases, copies of speeches, periodicals, photos, and frankincense government and corporate sources are attractive to media only for economic reasons. The third filter stresses that the opinions by corporate and state sources are adapted to class interest and market force.Herman and Chomsky stress that the nature of the mutual human relationship between media and sources directly affect the media performance. The powerful can use personal relationship s, threats, rewards, to influence media. The media under obligations whitethorn carry untrue stories in order not to offend their close relationship with the sources. The fourth filter, flak, means the state the dominant social institution which has power and resources to force the media to play a propagandistic role in societyHerman and Chomsky explain that flak refers to negative responses to media statement, it may involve individuals or independent action, and the authors contend that preferred meanings are structured by dominating authorised sources, in this way news may be skewed in the desired direction. The fifth filter, the anti-communism has been replaced by otherness Its the idea of scaring people, creating fear, hatred, and dissatisfy aroused by social and economic conditions, to prevent them from realizing to what is really happening to them.(Chomsky 1998 pg48).The authors maintain that media shapes public opinion by controlling how ideas are presented the five filte rs curb the flow of the news as it passes through its furnish and can easily limit what can be big news.Herman and Chomsky state that these five filter constraints are the essentials of propaganda model, the members of the power elite try to shape the beliefs and attitudes and opinions of the people through the media, relax and open discussions are part of the process but leaders utilize deceit and fury to combat individuals and institutions as the public does not agree with the opinion of the power elite. The world politics has seen radical changes since the demise of communism in the former(prenominal) Soviet Union as mentioned in the Manufacturing Consent.The fifth filter is termed the dominant ideology through out this book, however, anti communism has been emphasized as the ideological elements that are most important in terms of discipline and control mechanisms. The Manufacturing Consent, gives a vague description of the fifth filter its ideology helps to mobilize people against an foeman it can be used against any policies that threaten property interests or support the commie states and radicalism, the model presumes that media performance is understood as the outcome of market forces, the dominant media are deeply and hard imbedded in the market system, the main information sources ,the media depends on are the government and major business firms.Herman and Chomsky view media as dominant ideological apparatus same as mentioned in the thesis by William Domhoff in his book ,The Powers That Be Processes of Ruling Class Domination in America. (Domhoff 1979,pg 169). Domhoff contends that the four basic processes through which the notion class rules are (1)the special interest process(2)policy formation process(3)candidate selection and(4)the ideological process, the Herman and Chomskys theory is the mirror of Domhoffs theory of ideological apparatus for dominant elites.(Domhoff1979,179-183).The Canadian sociologist Wallace Clement writes approxima tely the ruling class of Canada, he states through observation that the ruling elite have remained consistent over the past century. The institutional links within Canada are at elite level, ownership of capital is highly concentrated.(Canadian Corporate selected1975). Another Canadian sociologist Patricia Marchak (1988pg122),stresses that the main question is under what conditions the state would be oblige to act only with reference to the interests of the capital. When such conditions are obtained universally, and when they do, the validity of Propaganda Model is likely to increase.(Patricia Marchak1988,pg34).Herman and Chomsky do not claim that media acts only to circulate propaganda. The Propaganda Model describes the forces that cause the mass media to play a propaganda role they besides argue that media not only table service the political and economic interests of dominant elite but withal of the state. The authors admit that the propaganda model does not explain everyth ing in every context it deals with the patterns of media behavior and performance. The elite media decides what topics, issues, and events that are to be considered news worthy by the lower-tier media and establish the general discourse, they determine, they select, they shape, they control, they restrict in order to inspection and repair the dominant elite groups in the society.This system is at odds with reality as the powerful are able to decide what the general public is allowed to see, hear, think and create public opinion by uninterrupted control. Individual powerlessness grows in the face of globalizing market support organizations as the labor unions are alter .In the final pages of Manufacturing Consent Herman and Chomsky acknowledge that the system is not all powerful, the domination of media by government and the elite have not overcome Vietnam syndrome and public hostility to direct US involvement in destabilisation and over throw of foreign governments. Herman and Ch omsky took the phrase manufacturing have from the influential American journalist Walter Lippman who advocated consent engineering.He said common good should be managed by small specialized class. The creation of consent is not a new art, it was supposed to have died out with the birth of democracy but it is very overmuch alive, it is now based on analysis rather than on rule of thumb. The engineering of consent is the centre of attention of democratic process, (Bernays 1947, cited in Wintonick and Achbar, 1994 pg41). the freedom of speech, press, petition, and assembly the freedoms to make the engineering of consent possible are the most cherished guarantees of the Constitution of the United States.(Lippman, cited inRai,1995pg23). John Jay was the first chief justice of the Supreme Court he said those who own the country ought to govern it in other words it is necessary to ensure that those who own the country are happy or else all will suffer, for they control investment and de termine what is produced and distributed and what benefits will trickle down to those who rent themselves to the owners when they can.The propaganda model contends that media content is organized to manufacture consent and to prevent immunity media content serves political ends the media makes choices that establish and define worthy and unworthy causes. The news coverage devoted to government(state)policy in general(foreign and domestic) by the elite to generate audience interest and sympathy in some stories while directive attention away from other stories Media take close interest in the Third World and their interconnections with the government.(Herman and Chomsky,1988pg13-14).The authors write that media treats victims of oppression and state terrorism differently, depending on the perpetrators. The unworthy victims (victims of oppression and /or state terrorism perpetrated by us (Canada, the US and the other capitalist democracies), and worthy victims (victims of oppression and/or state terrorism perpetrated by official enemy states).Different treatment is observed in sourcing and evaluating stories, full swing investigation in appear of villain and of high officials, to humane treatment more prominent coverage.In lawsuit of unworthy victims of enemy crimes, allegations are simply invented they have to rely on official US. sources unless they prove it wrong in which case they are avoided(Cambodia under Pol Pot is a case in point).It predicts that the victims of state terrorism/violence that is perpetuated by the democracies or client states will be given treatment that can be seen to serve political ends (Chomsky, 1988 pg34). The writers as moral agents are trying to bring the truth about matters of human deduction to an audience that can do something about them.My personal view is that citizens of democratic societies should take a decisive course of self- defense to protect their rights with the help of radio and television, advertising and publi c relations to safe control their rights from being manipulated. The Independent mind must be allowed to develop and grow in a free society it is a troublesome task as in todays free society, consent is manipulation of public opinion. I do agree with the writers, in my view the young minds should separate themselves from the official manipulative system. Thus the writers are invested with a moral responsibility to tell the truth, it is a very difficult task to perform today even in our free society.Works CitedClement, W. (1975) Canadian Corporate Elite Analysis of Economic Power. TorontoMcClelland and Stewart.Domhoff, William G. (1979) The Powers That Be Processes of Ruling ClassDomination in America. New York Vintage Books.European Journal of Communication (2002) SAGE Publications(London, Thousand Oaks, CA and New Delhi), Vol 17(2) 147182.02673231(200206)172 147182 023691Martin, Michele with Graham Knight (1997) Communication and Mass MediaCulture, Domination and Opposition. Toro nto Prentice-Hall.Wintonick, Peter and Mark Achbar (1994) Manufacturing Consent Noam Chomskyand the Media. Montreal Black Rose.